GENEVA (AP) – Through seven nations across three different parts of the world, Secretary of State Rex Tillerson devoted himself to his president’s overarching foreign policy mission: Defeating terrorism. His trip concluded Thursday with limited success.
In the Persian Gulf and Iraq, the top American diplomat sought to keep a region fracturing at the seams focused on defeating the Islamic State group and countering Iran. In Afghanistan, Pakistan and India, Tillerson addressed long-term plans for stabilizing an Afghan government besieged by the Taliban insurgency. In Switzerland, the former oil man dove back into the years-long drive to end Syria’s civil war, the origins of an IS threat that has spread worldwide.
All represented diplomatic moonshots. They remain so.
Speaking to reporters during his last stop in Geneva, Tillerson noted in understatement that many of the countries he visited over the last week “are still embroiled in significant conflict.”
Offering a grand vision of America’s role in the world, Tillerson said: “The United States will continue to provide global leadership, promote security, stability and prosperity for all people.” He then quickly pivoted to a more Trumpian theme about nations taking greater responsibility for their own problems, and international partners doing more to help.
The fact that two of Tillerson’s stops – Afghanistan and Iraq – had to be cloaked in secrecy and heavy security only underscored America’s failure to provide stability after committing to a decade-and-a-half of military efforts and trillions of dollars in each country.
And his message in several places appeared to fall flat.
Saudi Arabia and Qatar rebuffed the push to end a five-month old crisis between the American allies that has distracted from the U.S-led campaign to destroy IS.
In Baghdad, Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi was displeased with Tillerson’s call for Iranian-backed militia composed of mainly Iraqi fighters to “go home.” In Islamabad, government officials saw his demands for cracking down on extremist havens as lecturing.
Some of Tilleron’s other ambitious projects seem to rely on overturning all conventional wisdom.
Are Sunni-led Saudi Arabia and Shiite-majority Iraq going to join in a grand alliance against Iran?
Is Pakistan going to do anything that helps India shape the future of Afghanistan?
Are Syrian President Bashar Assad’s supporters, Russia and Iran, even willing to entertain any process to remove him from power – let alone Assad himself?
In a wide-ranging 40-minute discussion with reporters, Tillerson on Thursday rejected international complaints. He said he presented the Trump administration’s “asks” of these countries in a direct and frank manner.
On his pursuit of a Saudi-Iraqi front against Iran, he said, “What we’re saying to Iraq is you must develop a capacity to stand on your own and resist that influence.”
“Iraqis are Arab, they are not Persian. Whether it’s Iraqi Sunni or Iraqi Shia, it’s Iraqi Arabs, not Iraqi Persians,” Tillerson said, touting the enormous potential of an Iraqi partnership with the Saudis. “It’s important to facilitate Iraq standing on its own so that it doesn’t have to look only to the east.”
After meeting Tillerson in Riyadh and Baghdad this week, where they also a discussed a tense Iraqi-Kurdish dispute, al-Abadi promptly traveled to Tehran.
Tillerson’s stop in Afghanistan was overshadowed by an apparent attempt by the U.S. embassy and Afghan government to disguise the location of his meeting with President Ashraf Ghani and Chief Executive Abdullah Abdullah.
In tweets, statements and photographs, the embassy said the talks were in Kabul. In reality, the meeting took place in the heavily fortified Bagram Air Base north of the capital for security reasons. Tillerson and his party never left the facility and stayed there just over two hours.
Nonetheless, Tillerson said his talks with the Afghan leaders were productive and that they appreciated President Donald Trump’s new South Asia policy. The strategy leans heavily on counterterrorism and getting neighboring Pakistan to eradicate Taliban extremists from the remote areas on its soil they operate from.
The administration’s goal is to convince the Taliban that military victory over U.S.-backed Afghan forces is impossible, and to push the militants into negotiations by stopping them from finding refuge in Pakistan across the rugged, porous border.
The intense U.S. pressure is causing consternation in Pakistan, where officials suggested Tillerson’s conversations involving Prime Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi and military and intelligence chiefs were heavy-handed.
Tillerson denied such criticism. He said he spent 80 percent of his time in Islamabad listening, not talking. If Pakistan doesn’t heed requests to root out terrorist havens, he warned, the U.S. will seek other ways to achieve its aims.
“There’s nothing to be achieved by lecturing, but we should be very clear about expectations and what we’re asking,” Tillerson said, adding that the U.S. provided Pakistan with specific names and locations of extremists along with other information.
Now it expects action.
“If you decide you don’t want to do it, just let us know and we’ll adjust our plans accordingly,” Tillerson said he told the Pakistanis.
He added: “It’s not a threat.”